Wednesday, October 21, 2015

Gross Environmental Product will find its way in planning and policy making decisions, Initiative for Sustainable Development Begins

Doon University Inaugurates Workshop on Environmental Statistics 

The long awaited initiative on preparation of green GDP and presenting economic indicators in environment discounted terms was inaugurated today at DoonUniversitythrough the first technical workshop titled “PolicyMaking and Environmental Statistics for Sustainable Development”. The workshop organized jointly by the Department of Economics, Doon University and DES, Government of Uttarakhand is the first of its kind initiative that saw participation of policy makers, bureaucrats and academicians from different expertise on environment, economics, statistics and politics together on a single platform. Highlighting the objectives of the workshop, Dr. Manoj Pant from DES, Department of Planning said that the immediate purpose of the workshop is to build a framework of understanding on creation and maintaining of a framework of statistics on environmental goods, services and impacts on economic outcomes. But the longer term objective of any such process is to make efforts towards reversing the unbridled exploitation of resources and keep it within the limits of sustainability. Dr. B.M. Harbola, the registrar of the university welcomed the dignitaries and the guests. 

Prof. V.K. Jain, the vice chancellor, Doon University addressed the audience by focusing on the environmental issues which have direct impact on people, and how these issues create inequality among states and countries. He emphasized that the department of environmental science and natural resource management, department of economics and department of statistics must work together for better environmental accounting. Prof. Jain emphasized that there are three dimensions of looking at the issue of environmental statistics. Firstly, there is a need to estimate the level of our dependence on environmental resources. Secondly, the level at which we exploit and degrade the resources of our environment. Thirdly, it is also necessary to factor in the need to ensure social, regional and inter-generational equity as well as justice while using these resources for the material consumption needs of the present generation.  Dr. R.K. Sinha, Additional Secretary, Department of Planning GoUK,focused on the significance of the data, in the process of economic and social development. Credible data, honest feedbacks and rigorous methods are needed to ensure a sustained flow of information for effective policy making. The environmental scientist turned social activist and the leader of GaonBachaoAbhiyaan,Padmashree Dr. Anil Prakash Joshi, HESCO-founder highlighted the urgency to look at the economic indicators from the perspective of the marginalised and deprived sections of hilly region of Uttarkhand.He stressed that an expression of indicators like Green Environmental Product (GEP), might help in measuring the true developmental scenario of any region. He stressed that the current indicators of growth like GDP is an expression of the vulgar exploitation by the oppressive class that has been shamelessly appropriating the resources of the poor in the name of development. Dr. Manoj Pant, JD, DES gave a presentation focusing on the limitations of existing system of forest accounting, need of green GDP/GEP and ended his words with the quote “better statistics for better planning for better tomorrow”.  

Dr. Y.S. Pangtey described the inter-district disparities of Uttarakhand, how the 9 hilly districts are still underdeveloped and marginalized despite the abundant availability of natural resources, where as Dehradun. Haridwar,Udham Singh Nagar and Nainital contribute a major chunk of the state output and are the primary beneficiaries of the growth process so far. Accounts related to environmental degradation and use would actually serve the purpose of highlighting the contribution of the majority of population in the countryside in the hilly terrains of the state.

The first technical session started with a comparative perspective on the methodological divergences in preparation of environmental statistics at the global level, presented by Dr. Siba Sankar Mohanty of Department of Economics, Doon University. He stressed on the need for democratization of statistics by making all information free on the World Wide Web.

Dr. Meenakshi from HESCO, Dr. Rajesh Kumar-Director FSI, Government of India and DrRajwar from HNB Garhwal University presented the data gaps in the preparation of environmental statistics in the country.
Dr. PradeepChauhan, Economic Advisor to the Government of Himachal Pradesh presented the successful attempt of the Himachal Pradesh Government in preparing environmental statistics in the field of forestry and tourism. He stressed that it is not only a tool to look at the economic numbers from the ecological perspective; it is also a mechanism to control the excessive exploitation of the resources by keeping track of use by economic agents.

The workshop is potentially a step towards a larger effort to make our state a responsible user of resources, Mr. Y.S. Pangtey-Director DES remarked.

Wednesday, September 16, 2015

Discussion on “Labour Market Policies in Uttarakhand”

Discussion on
 “Labour Market Policies in Uttarakhand”
Date: 17th September 2015
Venue: Senate Hall, Doon University
Time: 2.30 P.M.

INVITATION
Dear Sir/Madam,

We are happy to invite you to participate in a discussion on “Labour Market Policies in Uttarakhand”.  The discussion is an open class of certain courses run by the department of Economics in which students get an exposure on the divergent view-points of practitioners on specific topics of interest.

The key discussants include, Sh. Hira Singh Bisht (State President INTUC and elected representative), Sh. Virendra Bhandari (General Secretary, CITU), Sh. Samar Bhandari (General Secretary, AITUC), Sh. Govind Singh Bisht (BMS, Tentative), Sh. Vijay Rawat (former professor and social activist), Sh. Ashok Chaudhary (Mahamantri, Uttaranchal Roadway’s Karamchari Union).

Kindly participate.

Sd/-

Dr. Siba Sankar Mohanty
Faculty-Economics,
School of Social Sciences,
Doon University, Dehradun



Sunday, August 30, 2015

Region and religion both matter for better population indicators

For better population indicators, region and religion both matter, suggest data from 2011 and 2001 decadal Censuses.  According to the data, in the more developed southern States all communities do better than in the more backward northern States.
Poor education indicators

Between 2001 and 2011, Muslims (24.65 per cent) remained the group with the fastest population growth, followed closely by Scheduled Tribes (23.66 per cent) and Scheduled Castes (20.85 per cent). All three groups have historically had poor education indicators, especially for women, and restricted access to health care.

However, in States such as Kerala and Tamil Nadu, which are considered advanced in terms of income and development indicators, population growth is low for all communities, the numbers show.
The population growth rate for Muslims in Kerala, for example, while substantially higher than that for Hindus or Christians in the State, is lower than the national average for Hindus, and half that of Hindus in States like Bihar.
“When the demographic transition is occurring, the better off communities first reduce their fertility, which is then followed by poorer communities. This is exactly what we are seeing, and in developed States, access to education and health becomes available to all,” Dr. P Arokiasamy, demographer and professor at the International Institute for Population Sciences, Mumbai, said.
A similar trend is observed in other States; those with higher than average Hindu growth rates have higher than average Muslim growth rates too.
Two notable exceptions are Assam and Uttarakhand, where the Muslim growth rate is significantly higher than the national average, while the Hindu growth rate is lower.
“It is undeniable that in the border districts of Assam, there is illegal immigration. There is no other explanation for the Muslim population growth there,” a senior Census official said.
Worst sex ratio
When it comes to sex ratio, Sikhs as a community had the worst sex ratio in 2011 at 903 females for every 1,000 males, followed by non-SC/ ST Hindus (929), while Christians had the best sex ratio (1,023 females for every 1,000 males) followed by STs (990). Here again, region matters.
In Punjab and Haryana, all communities see their sex ratios plummet to their worst, while in Kerala, the sex ratio of all communities except Sikhs and Buddhists rises above 1,000 females for every 1,000 males.
In Tamil Nadu, the sex ratio for Muslims, Christians and SCs rises above 1,000.

More children in school, but very few enter college

Over 400 million people, or over a third of the population in 2011, had never attended any school or educational institution, new numbers from the census show. According to the new data, while enrolment in school is now over 80 per cent for school-age children, higher education enrolment remains low.
Enrolment in educational institutions rose between 2001 and 2011 at every level, most of all in the primary and secondary school-going age of 7 to14 years. Between the age of 7 and 14, over 80 per cent of children are attending school, the numbers show.

In Kerala, the proportion of 7 to 14-year-olds attending school rose from 93 per cent to over 97 per cent. In all, however, there are still over 25.6 million children between the age of 6 and 14 who are out of school.
While girls still lag behind boys in educational enrolment at this age, the gap has substantially reduced over the last decade; school and college enrolment rose faster among girls than among boys.
Despite a substantial improvement over the last decade, less than two out of three young Indians in the age group of 15 to 19 go to any sort of educational institution, the census shows.
The proportion is lower for girls, in rural areas and among Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe students. In 2001, just 44 per cent of those aged 15 to 19 were in school or college, while in 2011 that proportion rose to nearly 60 per cent.
There is also wide inter-State variation. While the proportion of 15 to19-year-olds enrolled in school or college is the lowest in Odisha and Gujarat at 43.3 per cent and 51.1 per cent respectively, it is the highest in Himachal Pradesh (78.51 per cent) and Kerala (82.87 per cent).
Signalling the still low proportion of young Indians enrolling in graduate and postgraduate courses, fewer than 25 per cent of those aged 20 to 24 were enrolled in an educational institution in 2011.
Even in Kerala, the proportion is just over 30 per cent. For girls, nationally, the number is substantially lower, at under 20 per cent.
Those taking up vocational education remains extremely low. Between the age of 15 and 24, the proportion of those enrolled in a vocational institute is under 5 per cent. This figure is up from just over 2 per cent in 2001.


Wednesday, May 1, 2013

Are women really safe?

Mollyshree Dhasmana
M.Sc. Economics (2011)


Women are considered to the pride and respect of a nation and therefore their safety is considered as the responsibility of the people residing there. But India’s pride took a major hit when on December 16, 2012 a 23 years old girl was gang raped, tortured and brutally injured by a group of five people in a moving bus. This incident shocked the whole nation to their core and “humanity” was critically questioned.

The girl died after 13 days of treatment and struggle but left us all thinking and doubting the safety of women in our country. Several women suffer in India from harassment, physical abuse, assault that ranges from verbal harassment to crude preposition and in some cases even rape. Many of these incidents go unreported or as most of the times, unheard. This case made each and every one of us question the security and the law and order of the nation we live in and to what extent is the system damaged and how much repairing it needs. The girl who lost her life, “Damini” or “Nirbhaya” as she is know now, may have left the eyes of her loved ones moist but she opened our eyes and made us all rise and raise our voice to get what we deserve i.e. safety and security to walk the streets without any fear.

Read more about Are women really safe? | Gender Issues - @ www.lokkatha.com

Sunday, April 28, 2013

विकास का विरोधाभासी अनुभव


-अतुल सिंह 

कुछ समय पहले मैं अपनी नौकरी के दौरान दिल्ली में था | मैं अपने ऑफिस की बस में बैठा सड़कों - फ्लाईओवर के ऊपर से गुजर रहा था | और बस में बैठकर दिल्ली की ऐतिहासिक और आधुनिक सुंदरता के सामंजस्य का आनंद ले रहा था | कुछ देर बाद दिल्ली की सुंदरता के बीच मेरी आँखों ने जीवन का वह असामान्य दृश्य देखा जिसने मुझे हैरान तो किया ही सोचने पर भी मजबूर कर दिया |
एक फ्लाईओवर के नीचे एक महिला एक खाट पर लेटी हुई है, उसका तन ढकने को एक नाकाफी साडी है जो बहुत मैली लग रही है | उसके पास में एक बच्चा है जो काफी कमजोर है, शायद वह बच्चा कुपोषण का शिकार है | भला इसमें हैरान करने वाली क्या बात है ? ऐसे वाकये तो आसानी से देखने को मिल जाते हैं | तो इसमें हैरान करने वाली खास बात यह थी कि भले ही महिला के पास तन ढकने को एक ढंग की साडी नहीं थी, उसके बच्चे के पास खाने को पर्याप्त भोजन न हो पर वह महिला मोबाईल फोन पर बात कर रही थी | यह दृश्य देखकर मैं चकित था जिसने मुझे सोचने पर मजबूर कर दिया कि ये कैसा विकास है ? ऐसे विकास को किस तरह परिभाषित किया जाना चाहिए ? जहाँ एक तरफ फ्लाईओवर के ऊपर उच्च वर्ग के लोगों की महंगी महंगी गाडियां दौड रही हैं तो दूसरी तरफ उस महिला को मजबूर होकर फ्लाईओवर के नीचे दिन गुजारने पड़ रहे हैं और एक तरफ महिला के पास भले ही पहनने को पर्याप्त कपडे और बच्चे के लिए पर्याप्त भोजन न हो पर वह मोबाईल पर बात कर रही थी |
यह नज़ारा देखकर अनायास ही मेरे मन में भी दो दशकों से चल रही उदारीकरण पर बहस प्रारंभ हो गई | जिसमें एक वर्ग मानता है कि उदारीकरण का ही प्रभाव है कि भारत प्रगति कर रहा है और विश्वमंच पर अपनी कामयाबी की कहानी लिख रहा है | जबकि दूसरे वर्ग का मानना है कि उदारीकरण ने समाज में असमानता को बढ़ावा देने में मदद की है, उदारीकरण की नीतियों ने गरीब और असहाय लोगों को और पीछे धकेल दिया है | मैं भी इन्ही विचारों की उधेड़बुन में लग गया कि उदारीकरण ने सचमुच भारत में विकास की एक नयी नींव रखी है, ऊँची ऊँची इमारतें और उनमें बहुराष्ट्रीय कंपनियों के दफ्तर, ऊँचे ऊँचे फ्लाईओवर, उन पर दौड़ती महँगी महंगी गाडियां, मेट्रो ट्रेन, कंप्यूटर, आईफोन, मोबाईल आदि जो शायद इतनी जल्दी बिना उदारीकरण के संभव नहीं थे | पर उदारीकरण ही तो वो छुरी है जिसने हमारे समाज के आर्थिक रूप से पिछड़े वर्ग की पीठ पर गहरे घाव किये है | उदारीकरण की नीतियों के अंतर्गत ही सामाजिक सुरक्षाओं से जुडी योजनाओं के बजट में कटौती, आवश्यक सेवाओं पर मिलने वाली सब्सिडी को हटाना, निजीकरण आदि कई ऐसे निर्णय लिए गए जिन्होंने गरीब जनता के जीवन स्तर को नुकसान पहुँचाया है | बढती बेरोजगारी, मुद्रास्फीति और खाद्य वस्तुओं की बढ़ती दरें, किसानों द्वारा की जाने वाली आत्महत्याएं, नक्सलवाद और माओवाद कुछ ऐसे कारक है जो भारत के विकास की तस्वीर को विकृत करते हैं और कहा जाता है कि ये उदारीकरण की ‘कठोर’ नीतियों का ही परिणाम हैं |
सरकार की इन नीतियों पर प्रश्न उठना इसलिए भी स्वाभाविक है क्योंकि इन दो दशकों में उदारीकरण के अंतर्गत जो फैसले लिए गए और उनके जो परिणाम सामने आये हैं उससे पता चलता है कि भले ही कुछ लोगों को फायदा पंहुचा हो पर बहुसंख्यक जनता आज भी अपनी दो रोटी के लिए जद्दोजहद कर रही है | देश में विकास की गति को बेशक एक नयी रफ़्तार मिली है लेकिन अधिकांश लोगों के जीवन स्तर में सुधार की गति में आज भी कई अवरोधक हैं | इन नीतियों के परिणामों से संदेह होता है कि सरकारें अपनी प्राथमिकताओं कों भूल चुकी हैं | सरकार गाँव गांव को कम्प्यूटरीकृत और इन्टरनेट से जोड़ने की बात करती है लेकिन भूल जाती है कि आज भी कई गांव हैं जहाँ लोगों के पास दो वक्त का भोजन नहीं है, गांव में सड़कें नहीं हैं, अस्पताल और विद्यालयों के हालत बदतर हैं | सरकार के ही द्वारा बनायी गई गरीबी रेखा तय करने वाली सभी कमेटियों की रिपोर्ट बताती हैं कि आज भी देश की लगभग आधी जनता गरीबी रेखा के नीचे होते हुए अपना गुजर बसर कर रही है | इसी जनता को सरकारी अस्पतालों की नाकामी के कारण अपनी छोटी कमाई का एक चौथाई हिस्सा अपने स्वास्थय की देखभाल में खर्च करना पड़ता है | अधिकतर सरकारी विद्यालयों की शिक्षा का हाल सभी जानते हैं | शिक्षा कि स्थिति बताने वाली असर रिपोर्ट बताती है कि देश में बच्चों की शिक्षा का स्तर लगातार गिर रहा है | देश के प्रधानमंत्री स्वयं मानते हैं कि देश के आधे बच्चे कुपोषण का शिकार है और यह देश के लिए शर्म की बात है | ऐसे में क्या केवल विकास की गति सभी तक विकास पहुँचने का सही मानक है | भले कुछ शहरों में कुल जनसँख्या के एक छोटे हिस्से को विश्वस्तर की सुविधाएँ प्राप्त हों लेकिन बड़ा हिस्सा मूलभूत आवश्कताओं के लिए तरस ही रहा है | सरकार देश में हो रहे विकास का श्रेय लेना नहीं भूलती लेकिन जरूरी सुविधाओं को आम लोगों तक पहुचाने की अपनी प्राथमिकता को या तो भूल जाती है या जानबूझकर भुला देना चाहती है |

फिर अचानक उस महिला के विषय में ध्यान आया तो सोचने लगा कि क्या उस महिला को उदारीकरण, जिसके विषय में उसे जानकारी भी नहीं है, का शुक्रगुज़ार होना चाहिए कि भले ही उसके पास ठीक से खाने को भोजन और पहनने को कपडा ना हो पर वह मोबाईल पर बात कर रही है या उसे उदारीकरण का विरोध करना चाहिए जिसने उसके कई अधिकारों पर चोट पहुंचाई है कि उसके पास सिर ढकने को एक छत, पहनने को कपडा और खाने को भोजन नहीं है | तब कहा तो यह गया था कि उदारीकरण से होने वाला विकास रिस रिस कर गरीबों तक भी पहुंचेगा और वे भी इससे होने वाले विकास का फायदा उठा पाएंगे | लेकिन सरकार ने इस टिपण्णी पर कोई समय सीमा का वादा नहीं किया था शायद यह उस समय के लिए कहा गया था जब सारे गरीब इस उदारीकरण की भेंट चढ जायेंगे और कोई भी इसका फायदा उठाने के लिए बचेगा ही नहीं |

Wednesday, May 23, 2012

When Education Decides your Future, You Decide What Your Education Must Be: A Review of Economics Education at Doon University

When Siba Sankar Mohanty, Head of the Department of Economics, Doon University, asked me to prepare a review of the Department and the career potentials of the pass-outs of the School of Social Sciences, I was under the impression that he wanted me to prepare a promotional write up on the department. But in the course of preparation of this article I realised that the motive was rather to highlight 'Economics' as a trade in the career training of young professionals and to prepare an analysis of the extent to which, the Department of Economics, Doon University, is committed to cater to the need for fusion of the complex social and personal aspirations of young minds with the political and business aspirations of an emerging economy. What I have attempted to present here is an outcome of a month long exercise of collection of information, review of different universities in India and elsewhere, review of literature, interviews with students- parents and other faculty members of the Department and numerous sessions of discussion with Prof. Mohanty on the issues emerging out of such exercise. The task that was in no way  lesser than a research on contemporary debate on career goals and choice trade-offs, finally got shaped in the form of what follows. The author is only responsible for a compilation of secondary information and some perceptions, and is thankful to all who participated in the activity


Read more about When Education Decides your Future, You Decide What Your Education Must Be: A Review of Economics Education at Doon University  
Reviews by lokkatha.com

Saturday, May 5, 2012

Admission Notice: Department of Economics, Doon University

Click Here for the Admission Notice and Application Form Download


2-year MA Economics Programme
Eligibility: Graduates in any discipline, No of Seats: 20, Date of Entrance Test 17th May
5-Year Integrated MSc in Economics
 Eligibility: 12th from any Recognised Board, No of Seats: 30, Date of Entrance Test 17th May

Monday, April 23, 2012

A comparison of Population and covered area by The District of Uttarakhand

According to Census 2011 the total population of the India is 1,21,01,93422 and population of Uttarakhand is 1, 01, 16752 Uttarakhand population is 0.84 percent of India population.  Uttarakhand cover 1.69 percent area of India.


-Peeyush Sharma and Atul Singh

Employment in Organised Public and Private Sectors in the Era of Liberalisation

Employment in Public Sector in India has continuously declined from 1991 after the Economic Reforms. It declined from 190.58 lakh persons in 1991 to 176.74 lakh persons in 2008 In this Period central Government, Quasi Governments and Local Governments declined and State Governments increased marginally.


-Peeyush Sharma

Performance of India's Agriculture Sector

Mahatma Gandhi once said that India lives in village. Agricultural sector provides livelihood means for around two third of the workforce population of India, this sector is a source of employment for about 75 percent of the country’s population and around 43 percent of India’s geographical land is used for agricultural activities while its contribution in the total GDP is around 18 percent.


-Atul Singh

National Food Security Bill: Issues and Concerns

National food security bill was one of the key promises made by congress party in 2009 general elections after Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGS). On 18th December, 2011 the Union Cabinet cleared the bill that aims to provide subsidised food grains to over 63.5% of country’s population. The bill aims to provide food at subsidised rates to at least 90% of the rural population and 50% of the urban population.


-Meenakshi Dhyani

Polio Eradication In India: Miles to go in Health Outcomes Read more about Polio Eradication In India: Miles to go in Health Outcomes

‘INDIA achieved a milestone’, few days back this was the headline of all newspapers which was regarding the polio eradication in the country. Of course it was not less than achieving a milestone that now India did not find single case of polio anywhere in the country during last one year. January 13, 2012 was a great day in the history of Indian Public Health when the country completed 12 months period without any case of epidemic polio, since last case of polio was a two year old girl in West Bengal reported on 13 January last year.  This achievement of eradicating polio from the country is something worth celebrating.


- Atul Singh

Wednesday, July 20, 2011

COPING WITH CHINA



Based on a discussion at Doon University
 
Coping with china is one of the major issues for Indian economy. The question which arises is “Is it possible for India to cope up with china? If we compare the economies of both the countries, one can conclude the answer “NO”. India is amongst the fastest growing economy of the world, while china is growing with the “Accelerated Growth Rate”. Few say that the economy of china is “Artificial” while others comment on its development that it is a socialist country.
                If we compare the quality life of citizens for both countries, then according to me the life of Indians is much better than that of citizens of china. Although the HDI ranking of china is 81 while than that of India is much below which is 128.
                Political parties claim that India has a healthy relation with china. But sometimes “I wonder is it true”. China is going competition to every sector of Indian Economy. It is because of china that the small scale industries are getting closed down. In 2004 the major part of GDP was constituted by small-scale industries.
                China is making very friendly relation with our neighbor countries but not with us, this is the practical situation. If it is making good relation with Pakistan by building its airbase. China is making defense base in Nepal, Burma, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh. If we closely look to there move we can easily say that china wants to surround us from everywhere.
                India does not have defense strategy and it is ignoring the fact the china can attack. I think India has forgotten the attack of china in 1962, then prime minister Pt. Jawaharlal Nehru also claimed that we have very good relation with china.
                If we further look into the china we still remember the “Red Square Incident”, where around ten thousand people were crushed because they were protesting against the government. The country which is not taking care of its own citizens. Indian government expects that they would help them in the growth of the economy.
                The formal relation of both the countries is very strong, I agree of with this viewpoint but looking into the practical aspect I don’t agree. There is a famous saying that “China does not respect weak neighbors” and the history of china gives the example of this.
                Now if we talk about the comparison of the two economies then a famous economist of America has predicted that the GDP of china in 2040 would contribute to 40% of world GDP while that of India would be 17%. China is an Industrialised country wile India is agricultural country. China is considered as the global innovator, while has not innovated in last 2 decades. If we compare the Human Resource of both countries then the labour of both countries are cheap but the difference comes only that china has trained labour while India has unskilled labour.
                The problems faced by both countries are same poverty, population, illiterate dependency but still china is much ahead of India. It is of great concern that would it be possible for India to cope with china in the coming decade.

Friday, July 15, 2011

Brief Report on 2G Scam


2G SCAM IN INDIA


Introduction 

According to CAG report released in 2008, country bore the loss of Rs. 1.76 lac crore due to non-auctioning of the spectrum through the involvement of former Telecom minister A. Raja. According to an estimate, the money of Govt. or we can say common man which is robbed in 2G scam, with the same amount of money, food security could be provided to all the families below poverty line and above poverty line for two years. And with the same money, The Right to Education Act could be converted into the reality, it should be remembered that Rs. 35,000 crore is needed for the operations of Right to Education Act per year. Now it is clear that how many people could use these facilities but this 2G scam has deprived them. At present this 2G spectrum scam is the biggest scam in the Indian history.


Base of Allocation
             
On the basis of old prices of 2001, licenses were sold to nine companies in just Rs. 1651 crore each. While according to the CAG report, the price of each of these licenses was between Rs. 7442 crore to 47,912 crore. The CAG report states that “it was amply demonstrated between September 2007 and December 2008 that its (spectrum) demand in view of its scarcity was at its peak and thus would have fetched the market determined price at a much higher level than that of 2001 entry fee.  In spite of bidding, ‘first come first serve’ policy was used. Rules and procedures flouted while issuing licenses. Eighty five out of the 122 licenses issued in 2008, did not satisfy the basic eligibility conditions set by the DoT and had suppressed facts, disclosed incomplete information and submitted fictitious documents for getting licenses and thereby access to spectrum.



How Scam Happened?  
             
With the favouring decisions of A. Raja the licenses were allocated to the pet companies like SWAN Telecom and Unitech. Raja and his secretary and DoT secretary Sidharth Behura forcely provided licenses to liking companies. Ignoring the advice of the Prime Minister, and the Law Ministry, Raja went ahead with arbitrarily deciding that the cut-off date for issue of application of license would be advanced to September 25, 2007 and the applications received would be decided on first-come-first-serve (FCFS) basis, it was done only for the favouring companies. It is also seen that the Telecom Commission was not even consulted at the time of grant of 122 spectrum licences in 2008. On the prices of spectrum Raja overruled the Views and concerns TRAI, Ministry of Finance and Hon'ble Prime Minister's suggestions were not followed. On the allocation of 2G spectrum Ministry of Law and Justice advised a Group Of Minister to look after this process but it was also ignored.


Accused of Scam


Some known allegedly accused of the 2G spectrum scam are:

A. Raja                        -           Former Telecom Minister
R. K. Chandoliya        -           Secretary of A. Raja
Sidharth Behura         -           Former Telecom Secetary
Shahid Balwa              -           M.D., DB realty
P. J. Thomas               -           Secretary of the DoT
Kanimojhi                   -           Member of Rajyasabha


Probes in Scam

The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) investigating the 2G spectrum scam which has damaged a large amount of Govt. money. Other than CBI, two other committees has been set up to look into this scam.
Public Accounts Committee(PAC):
The report submitted by PAC Chairman Murli Manohar Joshi, which is most likely to be contested by members of the ruling UPA, Public Accounts Committee has held the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) and the Cabinet Secretariat responsible for failing to take ''corrective action'' while censuring the prime minister for ''some unfortunate omissions''.
Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC):
The whole winter session of Parliament violated because of the demand of setting up a Joint Parliamentary Committee. At last, in parliament on 22 February 2011 Prime Minister did the announcement of the setting up the JPC. Now the Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC), examining the 2G scam chaired by Congress leader P C Chacko, on the allocation and pricing of telecom licenses and spectrum.


Coclusion
             
This 2G spectrum scam is the biggest scam in Indian history, in which a central cabinet minister A. Raja misused his powers and with the Govt. Officers and owners of private companies made a loss of Rs.1.76 lac crore . If this amount of money would have used in the welfare of the society, a large no. of people could be helped through different appreciable schemes like Right to Education Act, Mid Day Meal, MNREGA, NRHM etc. These types of scams are the hurdles in the way of development in an economy. If these type of scam come into know regularly it would give heavy shocks to the growth of our economy and state of the country.


                                                                                                                                   By  Atul Singh



References:-
CAG report, Govt. Of India, 2008
NEWS from:-
IBN Live
NDTV
Dainik Jagran
Amar Ujala
The Hindu

Wednesday, October 6, 2010

A Brief on the Five Year Plans In India

Ramanpreet Kaur

When India gained independence, its economy was in disarray. The British had left the Indian economy crippled and the fathers of development formulated 5 years plan to develop the Indian economy. The five years plan in India is framed, executed and monitored by the Planning Commission of India. Currently, India is in its 11th five year plan. Following is a brief synopsis of the five year's plan in India

1st Plan (1951-56)

Year: 1951 to 1956
Total budget: 206.8 billion (INR) or USD$23.6 billion.
Target growth:2.1% (yearly) growth in gross domestic product.
Areas covered: India's five year plans, the 1st plan dealt with seven categories.
  • Agriculture as well as community development
  •   Energy as well as Irrigation
  •   Communications and transport
  •   Land rehabilitation
  •   Social services
  •   Miscellaneous
  •   Industrial sector
The first five year plan was presented by Jawaharlal Nehru in 1951. The First Five Year Plan was initiated at the end of the turmoil of partition of the country. It gave importance to agriculture, irrigation and power projects to decrease the countries reliance on food grain imports, resolve the food crisis and ease the raw material problem especially in jute and cotton. Nearly 45% of the resources were designated for agriculture, while industry got a modest 4.9%.The focus was to maximize the output from agriculture, which would then provide the impetus for industrial growth.
Though the first plan was formulated hurriedly, it succeeded in fulfilling the targets. Agriculture production increased dramatically, national income went up by 18%, per capita income by 11% and per capita consumption by 9%

2nd Plan (1956-61)

Objectives of the 2nd five year plan (1956 to 1961) - Industries got more importance in the 2nd five year plan. The focus was mainly on heavy industries. The Indian government boosted manufacturing of industrial goods in the country. This was done primarily to develop the public sector.

 

Mahalanobis Model:

 

The 2nd year five year plan functioned on the basis of Mahalanobis model. The Mahalanobis model was propounded by the famous Prasanta Chandra Mahalanobis in the year 1953. His model addresses different issues pertaining to economic development.

The second five year plan was initiated in a climate of economic prosperity, industry gained in prominence. Agriculture programmes were formulated to meet the raw material needs of industry, besides covering the food needs of the increasing population. The Industrial Policy of 1956 was socialistic in nature. The plan aimed at 25% increase in national income.

In comparison to First Five Year plan, the Second Five Year Plan was a moderate success. Unfavorable monsoon in 1957-58 and 1959-60 impacted agricultural production and also the Suez crisis blocked International Trading increasing commodity prices.
3rd Plan (1961-66)

Objectives of the 3rd five year plan:

  • Increasing the national income by 5 percent per annum.
  • Making India self sufficient by increasing agricultural production. This step was taken to ensure that India does not have to bank on others for food products.
  • Minimizing rate of unemployment.
  • Ensuring that people enjoy equal rights in the country.
     
While formulating the third plan, it was realized that agriculture production was the destabilizing factor in economic growth. Hence agriculture was given due importance. Also allotment for power sector was increased to 14.6% of the total disbursement.
Emphasis was on becoming self reliant in agriculture and industry. The objective of import substitution was seen as sacrosanct. In order to prevent monopolies and to promote economic developments in backward areas, unfeasible manufacturing units were augmented with subsidies. The plan aimed to increase national income by 30% and agriculture production by 30%.
The wars with China in 1962 and Pakistan 1965 and bad monsoon in almost all the years, meant the actual performance was way of the target.

4th Plan (1969-74)

The 4th five year plan of India also served as a stepping stone for the economic growth. The following section will highlight the main events that had taken place under the 4th five year plan.

Main events of the 4th five year plan:

1. India had to reform and restructure its expenditure agenda, following the attack on India in the year 1962 and for the second time in the year 1965. India had hardly recuperated when it was struck by drought. India also had a stint of recession. Due to recession, famine and drought, India did not pay much heed to long term goals. Instead, it responded to the need of the hour. It started taking measures to overcome the crisis.

2. Food grains production increased to bring about self sufficiency in production. With this attempt, gradually a gap was created between the people of the rural areas and those of the urban areas.

3. The need for foreign reserves was felt. This facilitated growth in exports. Import substitution drew considerable attention. All these activities widened the industrial platform.

Following the 4th Five Year Plan an alteration in the socio economic structure of the society was observed.

At the time of initiating the fourth plan it was realized that GDP growth and rapid growth of capital accumulation alone would not help improve standard of living or to become economically self-reliant. Importance was given to providing benefits to the marginalized section of the society through employment and education.
Disbursement to agricultural sector was increased to 23.3% .Family planning programme was given a big stimulus.
The achievements of the fourth plan were below targets. Agriculture growth was just at 2.8% and green revolution did not perform as expected. Industry too grew at 3.9%.

5th Plan (1974-79)

Contents of the 5th Five Year Plan


The 5th Five Year Plan was laid out during a crisis period to overcome the impediments posed by the wavering economic condition. The 5th Five Year Plan was designed in a way to meet the needs of the time. The issues that were emphasised were:
  Reducing the discrepancy between the economic development at the regional, national, international level. It emphasized on putting the economic growth at par with each other.
  Improving the agricultural condition by implementing land reform measures.
  Improving the scope of self-employment through a well integrated program.
  Reducing the rate of unemployment both in the urban and the rural sectors.
  Encouraging growth of the small scale industries.
  Enhancing the import substitution in the spheres including chemicals, paper, mineral and equipment industries.
  Applying policies pertaining to finance and credit in the industrial sector.
  Stressed on the importance of a labour intensive production technology in India.

As a result of inflationary pressure faced during the fourth plan, the fifth plan focused on checking inflation. Several new economic and non-economic variables such as nutritional requirements, health, family planning etc were incorporated in the planning process. Investment mix was also formulated based on demand estimated for final domestic consumption.
Industry got the highest allocation of 24.3% and the plan forecasted a growth rate of 5.5% in national income.
The fifth plan was discontinued by the new Janata government in the fourth year itself.

6th Plan (1980-85)

The Janata government moved away from GNP approach to development, instead sought to achieve higher production targets with an aim to provide employment opportunities to the marginalized section of the society. But the plan lacked the political will.
The Congress government on taking office in 1980 formulated a new plan with a strategy to lay equal focus on infrastructure and agriculture.
The plan achieved a growth of 6% pa.
During this time the Prime Minister was Rajiv Gandhi and hence industrial development was the emphasis of this plan. His idea about the betterment of the industrial sector was welcomed by some and opposed by lot others specially the communist groups. Even the workers who were more inclined towards the leftist ideology were not much convinced. This slowed down the pace of progress.

Transport and Communication System

The transport and communication system also improved under this Plan. The National Highways were all built during this time . Apart from the construction of new highways, the condition of the roads were meliorated. This helped in the betterment of the traffic system in India. During this time the Indian currency was devalued and this led to a dramatic increase in the number of foreign travelers in India thus helping India to become a tourist destination.

New Introduction on the Economic Front

Economic Liberalization was introduced for the first time in India during this period. Ration shops were closed because government no more produced articles at a subsidized rate. Price control measures were no more useful. As a consequence the prices of various goods increased leading to growth in the standard of living of the residents of India.

Measures against Population Explosion

Family Planning was implemented for the first time in India. Family Planning helped to create awareness among the Indians regarding population. However, this measure to control population was not accepted across India. It was readily accepted by the people residing in the developed areas of the country but the mass of the less developed areas refused to accept the plan and never implemented it.

7th Plan (1985-89)


The basic issues on which this plan put stress were:

  • Introduction and application of modern technology
  • Justice meted out to people from various social stratas
  • Improving the position of the weak in the Indian society
  • Development of agriculture
  • Reducing poverty in India
  • Assuring the essentials of food, shelter and clothing to the people
  • Striving to achieve independence as per the Indian economy is concerned
  • Help the small as well as the large farmers to increase their productivityThis time Indian government was adamant to achieve self-sufficiency in the economic and production sector. They endeavored to develop on the factors that ensure a persistent growth in the economy. The rate of employment was anticipated to rise by 4% every year and the labor force was anticipated to grow by 39 million at the end of fifth year.
Overall improvement was the aim of the 7th Five Year Plan. Therefore care was taken to establish a harmony in all the sectors that are contained in an economy. Special care was taken to spread education among girls, enhance telecommunication within the country. The government of India also strove to maintain a balance in the economy and by striking a balance within export and import.
 
The first three years of the seventh plan saw severe drought conditions, despite which the food grain production rose by 3.2%.Special programmes like Jawahar Rozgar Yojana were introduced. Sectors like welfare, education, health, family planning, employment etc got a larger disbursement.

It may be noticed that the period between 1989 to 1991 seems to lie idle. But according to the trend, these years should have been included. But this period was characterized by political unrest. This period witnessed many changes.

8th Plan (1992-97)

The eighth plan was initiated just after a severe balance of payment crisis, which was intensified by the Gulf war in 1990.several structural modification policies were brought in to put the country in a path of high growth rate. They were devaluation of rupees, dismantling of license prerequisite and decrease trade barriers.
The plan targeted an annual growth rate of 5.6% in GDP and at the same time keeping inflation under control.
The basic objective of this period was the modernization of industrial sector. This plan focused on technical development. Through this plan the reduction of deficit and foreign debt was aimed at. The rectification of certain flawed plans and policies were also done under this five year plan. During this period only India received a coveted opportunity to become a member of the World Organization on January 1st 1995.

Agricultural Activities During this Period

Agriculture happens to be the largest contributor to the GDP of India. In fact two third of the work force was dependent on agriculture. Industries also made use of agricultural produce as inputs in their production process.

Self-Sufficiency in Agricultural Production

Self-sufficiency in agricultural production was a top priority during India's eighth Five Year Plan since most of the population depended on that. Production of food increased to 176.22 million from 51 million which was a huge leap in comparison to the previous years.

9th Plan (1997-2002)

It was observed in the eighth plan that, even though the economy performed well, the gains did not percolate to the weaker sections of the society. The ninth plans therefore laid greater impetus on increasing agricultural and rural incomes and alleviate the conditions of the marginal farmer and landless laborers.
The main objectives of the Ninth Five Year Plan India were:
  • to prioritize agricultural sector and emphasize on the rural development
  • to generate adequate employment opportunities and promote poverty reduction
  • to stabilize the prices in order to accelerate the growth rate of the economy
  • to ensure food and nutritional security
  • to provide for the basic infrastructural facilities like education for all, safe drinking water, primary health care, transport, energy
  • to check the growing population increase
  • to encourage social issues like women empowerment, conservation of certain benefits for the Special Groups of the society
  • to create a liberal market for increase in private investments
During the Ninth Plan period, the growth rate was 5.35 per cent, a percentage point lower than the target GDP growth of 6.5 per cen

10th Plan (2002-2007)

Chief Objectives of the 10th Five Year Plan:

  • The Tenth Five Year Plan proposes schooling to be compulsory for children, by the year 2003.
  • The mortality rate of children must be reduced to 45 per 1000 livings births and 28 per 1000 livings births by 2007 and 2012 respectively
  •  All main rivers should be cleaned up between 2007 and 2012
  •   Reducing the poverty ratio by at least five percentage points, by 2007
  •   Making provision for useful and lucrative employments to the population, which are of the best qualities
  •   According to the Plan, it is mandatory that all infants complete at least five years in schools by 2007.
  •   By 2007, there should be a decrease in gender discriminations in the spheres of wage rate and literacy, by a minimum of 50%
  •   Taking up of extensive afforestation measures, by planting more trees and enhance the forest and tree areas to 25% by 2007 and 33% by 2012
  •   Ensuring persistent availability of pure drinking water in the rural areas of India, even in the remote parts
  •   The alarming rate at which the Indian population is growing must be checked and fixed to 16.2%, between a time frame of 2001 and 2011
  •   The rate of literacy must be increased by at least 75%, within the tenure of the Tenth Five Year Plan
  • There should be a decrease in the Maternal Mortality Ratio (MMR) to 2 per 1000 live births by 2007.
  • The Plan also intended to bring down the Maternal Mortality Ratio to 1 per 1000 live birth by the year 2012.
The aim of the tenth plan was to make the Indian economy the fastest growing economy in the world, with a growth target of 10%.It wanted to bring in investor friendly market reforms and create a friendly environment for growth. It sought active participation by the private sector and increased FDI's in the financial sector.
Emphasis was laid on corporate transparency and improving the infrastructure.
It sought to reduce poverty ratio by 5 percentage points by 2007and increase in literacy rates to 75 per cent by the end of the plan.
Increase in forest and tree cover to 25 per cent by 2007 and all villages to have sustained access to potable drinking water.

11th Plan (2007-2012)

The eleventh plan has the objective to increase GDP growth to 10%.
Increase agricultural GDP growth to 4% per year to ensure a wider spread of benefits. Create 70 million new work opportunities. Augment minimum standards of education in primary school.
Reduce infant mortality rate to 28 and malnutrition among children of age group 0-3 to half of its present level. Ensure electricity connection to all villages and increase forest and tree cover by five percentage points.
The eleventh plan has the following objectives:
  1. Income & Poverty
    • Accelerate GDP growth from 8% to 10% and then maintain at 10% in the 12th Plan in order to double per capita income by 2016-17
    • Increase agricultural GDP growth rate to 4% per year to ensure a broader spread of benefits
    • Create 70 million new work opportunities.
    • Reduce educated unemployment to below 5%.
    • Raise real wage rate of unskilled workers by 20 percent.
    • Reduce the headcount ratio of consumption poverty by 10 percentage points.
  2. Education
    • Reduce dropout rates of children from elementary school from 52.2% in 2003-04 to 20% by 2011-12
    • Develop minimum standards of educational attainment in elementary school, and by regular testing monitor effectiveness of education to ensure quality
    • Increase literacy rate for persons of age 7 years or above to 85%
    • Lower gender gap in literacy to 10 percentage point
    • Increase the percentage of each cohort going to higher education from the present 10% to 15% by the end of the plan
  3. Health
    • Reduce infant mortality rate to 28 and maternal mortality ratio to 1 per 1000 live births
    • Reduce Total Fertility Rate to 2.1
    • Provide clean drinking water for all by 2009 and ensure that there are no slip-backs
    • Reduce malnutrition among children of age group 0-3 to half its present level
    • Reduce anaemia among women and girls by 50% by the end of the plan
  4. Women and Children
    • Raise the sex ratio for age group 0-6 to 935 by 2011-12 and to 950 by 2016-17
    • Ensure that at least 33 percent of the direct and indirect beneficiaries of all government schemes are women and girl children
    • Ensure that all children enjoy a safe childhood, without any compulsion to work
  5. Infrastructure
    • Ensure electricity connection to all villages and BPL households by 2009 and round-the-clock power.
    • Ensure all-weather road connection to all habitation with population 1000 and above (500 in hilly and tribal areas) by 2009, and ensure coverage of all significant habitation by 2015
    • Connect every village by telephone by November 2007 and provide broadband connectivity to all villages by 2012
    • Provide homestead sites to all by 2012 and step up the pace of house construction for rural poor to cover all the poor by 2016-17
  6. Environment
    • Increase forest and tree cover by 5 percentage points.
    • Attain WHO standards of air quality in all major cities by 2011-12.
    • Treat all urban waste water by 2011-12 to clean river waters.
    • Increase energy efficiency by 20 percentage points by 2016-17